Marie Calloway rocks. No two ways
about it, she rocks the Casbah. Since the release of ‘Adrien Brody’ she’s
become popular. A few people (who am I kidding) a lot of people have criticized
her in ways that I find particularly unflattering, dishonest, and downright
mean. Originally I wasn’t going to write about Marie, she’s an internet friend
of mine and a supporter of mine. I figured ‘Oh, people will get around to her
point of view; the internet shit-storm (caused mostly by double standards,
sexism, etc.) will subside’. I thought of people’s initial reaction to Megan
Boyle’s work “Everyone I’ve Had Sex With” as a similar comparison and the
‘shit-storm’ that came immediately after it. What came of that was Megan’s
book, which ended up doing really well, with haters either silenced or
outvoted. I wanted that to happen with Marie as I left on hiatus. I figured by
the time I came back from the most remote corner of Earth people would gain
some common sense and decency.
That
hasn’t happened. That’s why I’m writing this piece. I support Marie Calloway’s
writing and am offended that people use thinly veiled criticism of her life as
a way to insult her work. Really they shouldn’t be criticizing Marie at all, at
least not in such vicious and counterproductive ways. When I initially read the
comments on HTML Giant, I said aloud to myself ‘I wonder how many of these
people bothered reading Marie’s story, or do they just dislike the idea behind
the story’. I don’t know the answer to this question, I hope everyone who
criticizes her has at the very least read her work, but that’s probably not the
case. 15,000 words is a lot to read and I know to criticize takes less effort
than to create. But to do this justice to some degree requires starting at the
beginning, to her Thought Catalog articles.
Thought
Catalog is a wonderful, lovely place where people contribute stellar material. There
are some commenters who fight amongst themselves. It is a place kind enough to
have hosted my writing before (see here). It gave Marie her first outlet for
writing starting in April of last year. I’ll summarize them briefly here:
‘Losing Your Virginity’ is the best summary for the article. It is also the title. It
is an extremely descriptive version of the experience, told from a female point
of view, a refreshing take from ‘then we boned and it was hot.’ This should have alerted people to Marie’s
writing abilities, particularly the ending of the piece. Going through the
comments gives only an inkling of what kind of Puritan Rage Marie would later
encounter with ‘Adrien Brody’. A few of them are point out her refusal to
capitalize words. Others penned such lazy comments as ‘she just wants
attention, blah blah blah’ and other extraordinarily useful critiques. The
comments were swipes at her age, gender, and socio-economic status.
‘How to Make Money in London’ is the second piece. It deals with the sex economy and
the power dynamic between Marie and a London Banker. At least that’s what I got
from it. People got pissed off by the ‘banker listens to the Smiths’ line. I
mean, I’m a music nerd. No doubt about it. But I can’t understand why people
got infuriated by the Smiths line so much. A few of them even suggested ‘do the
math’ since they are unable to do basic addition and subtraction. Weirdly, even
though this was about sex work, people seemed less upset than they did about
Marie losing her virginity. Guess since it was prostitution and not outright ‘I
must enjoy this sex’ people relax. Commenters feel threatened when faced with a
different story from what TV, literature, culture, etc. has told them about
sex. Prostitution though is treated in a darker light, hence why people did not
berate her as much for this article. A simpler explanation exists: people read
her first piece and already had some idea what to expect from her re: subject
material, style and tone.
‘Adrien Brody’: this is the big one, the one that tore bored, apathetic bloggers apart,
no mean feat. Read it here. Much of the criticism was pathetic. One critic
penned something with the truly Earth shattering, brilliant fucking insight of
‘What would your Father say?’ which somehow became an entire blog post with
likes and stuff. Honestly, who cares what her father says? In what way does
that change the content of the story, what the story covered, the relationship
dynamic between Adrien and Marie, or really anything? Then there are the ‘when
you’re older you will realize how stupid you are’ critics. They claim she’ll
regret everything she did as a young writer. I’m kind of shocked that so-called
‘smart people’ people who went into an MFA program, paid for the education, and
write full time could be so emotionally stupid. I don’t get it. Why are so many
alt lit readers such prudes? The ‘Marie’ character in the story is not the
exact same person who wrote it, there are differences and changes that Marie
has explained over and over again, only to hear people use the same critiques
over and over again. The mean-spirited destructive criticism Marie Calloway has
received makes me sad. I told a close friend of mine about it and they
suggested we go together to see Marie read live when she comes to New York in
February.
What is
‘Adrien Brody’ about though? It is about a young woman (our heroine Marie)
going to New York and sleeping with an older (smarter?) man. I liked a lot of
parts of this story. I liked how he uses parts of her conversation in his
actual IRL articles (hence evidence that she’s a good writer). See the Forever
21 conversation for evidence. Hearing how he is a bit of a phony when it comes
to reading is pretty funny. Books he never read are just one of many details.
By the end of the story I felt for the character Marie. Parts of the dialogue
were quite charming, touching my slothy heart.
"So why did you break up?"
"Because I didn't love him."
"I guess that is important..."
I
enjoyed that snippet and other pieces. If I was to cut and paste every part I
enjoyed it would be enormous. I liked the Hipster Runoff discussion, the Tao
Lin discussion, and a lot of other little details. Every little piece is
brought together right down to Adrien’s borough of residence Queens. To that I
say ‘Hell Yeah’ because Queens never gets any love in any story.
Since
the story came out Marie has been busy. She’s interview Momus, a musician she’s
fond of, and she’ll be doing some fantastic readings in the Big Apple, New York
City. Hopefully I can make those given time, space, buses, money, and so many
other variables.
Marie
also runs probably one of the most kickass Tumblrs I’ve seen in quite some
time. Go here to witness pure joy, pure happiness, and pure Mountain Mew. <3
Mew Marie Cattoway.













